Sefer HaMitzvot (negative commandment 184) and Sefer HaChinuch (mitzvah 148) include this prohibition among the 613 mitzvot of the Torah. If he does so inadvertently, he is liable to bring a fixed sin-offering.3This term is used to differentiate this offering from a guilt offering whose value is adjusted according to the person's means.
It is explicitly stated in the Torah that he is liable for partaking of blood from all domesticated animals, wild beasts, and fowl alone. This applies whether they are from a non-kosher or kosher species,4In contrast to the prohibition against partaking of cheilev, forbidden fat, which applies only with regard to kosher species of domesticated animals. as [Leviticus 7:26] states: "You may not partake of any blood from a fowl or an animal in all your dwellings." A wild beast is considered as an animal as [Deuteronomy 14:4-5] states: "These are the animals that you may eat: an ox... a gazelle and a deer...."5I.e., the verse uses the term behemah which more specifically refers to domesticated animals and mentions both domesticated animals and wild beasts.
One is not, [by contrast,] liable for transgressing of the prohibition against partaking of blood6One may, however, be liable for another prohibition as the Rambam continues to explain. for partaking of the blood of fish, locusts, creeping animals, teeming animals, or humans. Therefore it is permitted to partake of the blood of kosher fish and locusts. Even if one collects it in a container and drinks it, it is permitted.7The Ra'avad and the Maggid Mishneh note that Keritot 21a states that it is permitted to partake of fish blood that has been collected only when fish scales are placed in it. Otherwise, it is forbidden because of the impression that may be created. The Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 66:9) quotes this view. The blood of non-kosher fish and locusts is forbidden because it comes from their bodies like the milk of a non-kosher animal.8As apparent from Chapter 3, Halachot 1 and 6, although this prohibition is of Scriptural origin, it is not punishable by lashes. See also Chapter 3, Halachah 22. The blood of creeping animals is comparable to their bodies, as we explained.9Chapter 2, Halachot 9-10.
When does the above apply? With regard to the heart of a fowl, because it does not contain an olive-sized portion of blood.20The heart of a fowl is not large enough for there to be an olive-sized portion of blood absorbed within its meat before slaughter. And it is only that blood for which one is liable for karet. If an olive-sized portion of blood collects there when the animal is slaughtered, one is liable for lashes. If, by contrast, one [partakes] of the heart of an animal, one is liable for karet. For there is an olive-sized portion of blood within the heart and therefore one is liable for karet.21This indicates that according to the Rambam, even when one cooks blood, one is liable for kereit for partaking of it (Lechem Mishneh). Other authorities differ and maintain that if blood has been cooked or salted, one is not liable according to Scriptural Law (Siftei Cohen 87:15).
The liver must be cut open thoroughly so that the blood contained in the blood vessels inside of it will flow out. Afterwards, placing it in vinegar or hot water causes the blood to be sealed in its place and not to flow into other portions of the liver. It is only blood that flows from place to place within the meat itself that is forbidden (Kessef Mishneh). and casts it into vinegar or boiling water until it turns white, it is permitted to cook it afterwards.23Implied is that if one desires to roast it, there is no difficulty (Maggid Mishneh).
Many opinions maintain that we are not knowledgeable with regard to the process of casting a liver in vinegar or boiling water in the present age and should not rely on this practice. This view is quoted in the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 73:2). It has already become universal Jewish custom to singe it over a fire24See the Rambam's Commentary to the Mishnah (Terumot 10:11) where the Rambam mentions ordinary roasting and not singeing for the liver to be permitted. and then cook it. [This applies] whether one cooks it alone or one cooks it with other meat.25The Rama (Yoreh De'ah 73:1) states that it must be roasted to the extent that it is fit to be eaten. The Siftei Cohen 73:2 explains that this means that it must be roasted at least half the extent to which one would normally roast it.
Similarly, it is a common custom that the brains are not cooked nor roasted until they are singed over a fire.26The Maggid Mishneh states that this custom is not as widespread as the custom of singeing the liver. Instead, he writes that it is customary to cut open the membrane surrounding it and then to salt it thoroughly. See the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 71:3).
It is permitted to roast a liver together with other meat on one spit, provided the liver is positioned below [the other meat].28For then the blood will not flow from the liver to the other meat. Hence, even at the outset, this is permitted. The Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 73:4) states that this ruling applies with regard to the ovens that existed in the Talmudic era. In the present era, however, it is common to turn the spit upside down. Hence, one should not roast the liver together with other meat. If one transgressed and roasted it while it was positioned above the meat, [after the fact,] one may eat it.
When one breaks the neck of an animal before its soul expires, the blood is absorbed into the limbs.30I.e., the animal suffers internal bleeding when its neck is broken. Since it is in the midst of expiring, it does not have the potential to expel this blood from its system. Instead, it becomes absorbed in its meat [Tur (Yoreh De'ah 67)]. It is forbidden to eat raw meat from it even if one causes the blood to be sealed.31By casting it into vinegar or boiling water.
To explain the difficulty the Rambam is addressing: There is a certain amount of blood absorbed in the meat of an animal. It is forbidden to partake of blood that has moved from place to place within an animal's body and cooking meat will certainly cause such movement. To avoid this difficulty, we salt meat, for this removes the blood. Casting meat in vinegar or boiling water does not remove blood, but instead causes it to be sealed in its place without moving even when the meat is cooked. Hence, according to the Rambam, this process is effective for ordinary meat. It is not, however, effective in this instance, for the internal bleeding that resulted from the breakage of the neck leaves blood that is not in its natural place (Kessef Mishneh, see also his gloss to Halachah 12). What should be done? One should cut open32Our translation follows the gloss of the Lechem Mishneh who states that one should cut open the meat to allow its blood to flow out. The Maggid Mishneh states that it is unnecessary to cut open the meat and his view is accepted by the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 67:3). The Rama, however, states that at the outset, one should be stringent. the piece and salt it thoroughly and afterwards, cook it or roast it.33It is then permitted, because the salting removes all the blood.
We have already explained34Chapter 4, Halachah 13. In that chapter, the emphasis was that the animal was not dead when slaughtered. Here the Rambam is restating the law to emphasize that we do not fear that the blood became absorbed within the meat and will not be released through salting. that when a person slaughters a domesticated animal, wild beast, or fowl and no blood emerges, they are permitted.
a) it removes the blood on the external surface of the meat;
b) it softens the meat and enables the blood inside to flow out more easily;
c) it enables the salt to adhere well to the surface of the meat. and afterwards, salt it thoroughly. One should leave it in the salt for the time it takes to walk a mil36A mil is a Talmudic measure equivalent to approximately a kilometer. According to many Rabbinic opinions, it takes 18 minutes to walk a mil. [This view is cited in the present context by the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 69:6).] The Rambam, however, follows a more stringent view [see his Commentary to the Mishnah (Pesachim 3:2)] and requires 24 minutes.
The Rama states that these measures are acceptable only after the fact or when there is an urgent need to prepare meat quickly. Otherwise, meat should be allowed to soak in water for at least half an hour. and then wash it thoroughly, [continuing] until clean water emerges.37This washing removes the salt and blood from the meat. The Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 69:7) states that the meat should be washed twice and the Rama requires a third washing. Immediately afterwards, one should cast it into boiling water - warm water is not [sufficient] - so that it will become white immediately and [no further] blood will be released.38This follows the Rambam's view that we are knowledgeable in the process of casting meat into hot water to seal it in its place. (As mentioned above, there are many who maintain that we lack that knowledge.) Moreover, in this instance, once the meat has been salted, there is no need for this measure, because all its blood has been released. For this reason, the Ra'avad and the Maggid Mishneh object to the Rambam's ruling. It is, however, mentioned by the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 69:19).
We salt it only with thick salt that resembles coarse sand. [The rationale is that] salt that is thin like flour will be absorbed by the meat and will not extract the blood.40The Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 69:3) states that one should be careful not to use salt with overly large crystals for they will not adhere to the meat. The Rama adds that if one has only thin salt, it is permitted to salt meat using it.
One must shake the salt from the meat before washing it.41For the water will stop the meat from releasing blood. Afterwards, the salt may cause the blood on the surface to be reabsorbed into the meat (Siftei Cohen 69:27).
The Maggid Mishneh states that the Rambam's words imply that he maintains that one must salt meat before roasting it. There are other Rabbinic opinions that do not accept that approach. (They are favored by the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 76:1).
The Rashba emphasizes that if one salts meat and does not roast it immediately, he should wash off the salt and the blood. Otherwise, the blood may become reabsorbed. The Rama rules that one should wash meat and salt it slightly before roasting it and should roast it directly after salting it.
When a person desires to eat raw meat, he should salt it thoroughly43The Rambam's statements have attracted the attention of the commentaries, for they appear to contradict his approach in Halachah 9 and in the latter clause of this halachah. To explain: From Halachah 9, it would appear that it is forbidden to eat raw meat that is not salted only when there is internal bleeding while the animal is being slaughtered. For although the meat contains blood, that blood is forbidden only when it moves from one part of the meat to another while cooking. If one eats the meat raw, such a transfer will not take place.
Similarly, the latter clause of this halachah permits meat when it is cast into vinegar because the blood becomes sealed in its place. Implied is that the blood itself is permitted.
This clause, by contrast, states that one must salt the meat to remove the blood even when one eats the meat without cooking it. Implied is that the blood is forbidden even though it has not moved from place to place within the meat. The Kessef Mishneh resolves the contradiction, explaining that since the blood is fit to move from place to place, it is forbidden. Hence, the latter clause which speaks about blood that is sealed in its place does not represent a contradiction. Similarly, this interpretation allows Halachah 9 to be understood in a manner that does not produce a contradiction.
It must be emphasized that the Ra'avad and many other authorities object to the Rambam's ruling and maintain that as long as the blood has not actually moved from place to place, it is not forbidden. Therefore it is permitted to partake of raw meat without salting it. It must, however, be washed thoroughly to remove all blood on its surface. This view is cited by the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 67:2). and wash it thoroughly. If he causes the blood to be sealed [by casting the meat into] vinegar, it is permitted to eat the meat while raw.44As mentioned previously, in the Ashkenazic community (and also among many Sefardim), the custom of sealing blood by casting meat into vinegar is no longer practice. See Rama (Yoreh De'ah 67:6). And it is permitted to drink the vinegar which sealed it, for vinegar does not extract blood.
When meat turns red,47An indication that it has absorbed additional blood. similarly, the testicles of an animal or beast and their membranes,48For they also contain large quantities of blood. See Chulin 93a. and similarly the neck which contains large blood vessels that are filled with blood, it is permitted to cook them if they are cut open and salted as required. If one did not cut them open and instead roasted them on a spit, they are permitted if he roasted the neck with its opening facing downward or he roasted all of them on the coals themselves.
Should he [roast it] with its nose positioned downward, if he places a straw or a reed in its nose so that it will remain open and the blood can flow out through it, [the brain] is permitted. If not, it is forbidden.
The Maggid Mishneh writes that there are opinions that we are not familiar with the details of this process. Hence one should not rely on this leniency. This approach is followed by the Tur and the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 76:6) which state that one should not place a utensil under the meat until the meat is roasted to the extent that it can be eaten.
When fish and fowl are salted together, even in a utensil with holes, the fish are forbidden. [The rationale is that] the fish is soft and will absorb the blood which is being exuded by the fowl.58Generally, when pieces of meat are being salted together and the utensil has holes so that the blood can run off, the meat is permitted even if the blood from other meat flows over it. The rationale is that since it is expelling its own blood and/or other juices, it will not absorb blood. Fish, however, will expel its blood and juices far faster than meat or fowl and will complete that process before the meat completes expelling its blood. Hence, we fear that it will absorb the blood from the meat or fowl (Maggid Mishneh).
All that is forbidden is the external surface of the fish (kedai kelipah). Once that is cut off, the remainder of the fish is permitted [Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 70:1)]. The Rama rules that all the fish are forbidden. This stringency applies when the fishes' scales have been removed. If they have not been removed, the fish are permitted. Needless to say, [this law applies] if one salted fish together with the meat of an animal or beast.
Alternatively, the Rambam's ruling can be understood according to the statements of the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 77:1) who rules that initially one must salt both sides of the fowl. If the fowl was already stuffed, salting just the exterior is not sufficient, because it will not effect the blood on the inside. See also the Rama who rules that at the outset, fowl must be salted properly and any meat placed within it must be salted properly. Only in such a situation should one cook a fowl with stuffing. and even if the meat inside them was cooked or roasted. If one roasted [the fowl], they are permitted.61For the fire will cause all the blood to drain out. [This applies] even if the meat inside them was raw and even if their opening was pointed upward.62Even in such a position, the power of the fire will cause the blood to drain downward.
From the Rambam's ruling (here and in Chapter 17, Halachah 7), it appears that he maintains that the animal's neck is not "hot." Nevertheless, he requires certain safeguards in consideration of the other views.
This issue is a matter of concern only when the meat being cut itself is hot. For otherwise, the blood absorbed in the knife will not be transferred to it.
The Maggid Mishneh mentions that there is another opinion which maintains that even though the animal's neck is cold, the pressure of cutting causes the knife to absorb some blood. See the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De'ah 10:2) and commentaries. unless the knife was exposed to fire until it turned white, sharpened in a sharpener or inserted into hard earth ten times. [After the fact,] if one cut hot meat with it, it is permitted.
Similarly, one should not cut radishes or other sharp foods69Since these foods are sharp, they produce an effect similar to actual heat and have the potential to affect forbidden foods absorbed in a knife. Therefore safeguards should be taken. with it at the outset. If one washed the knife or cleaned it with a utensil, it is permitted to cut radish and the like with it, but not hot meat.
הלכות מאכלות אסורות פרק ו
א) האוכל כזית מן הדם -- במזיד, חייב כרת; בשוגג, מביא חטאת קבועה. ודבר מפורש בתורה שאינו חייב אלא על דם בהמה חיה ועוף בלבד, בין טמאין בין טהורין, שנאמר "וכל דם לא תאכלו, בכול מושבותיכם -- לעוף, ולבהמה" (ויקרא ז,כו), וחיה בכלל בהמה, שנאמר "זאת הבהמה, אשר תאכלו... אייל וצבי, ויחמור" (דברים יד,ד-ה). אבל דם דגים וחגבים ושקצים ורמשים, ודם האדם -- אין חייבין עליו משום דם; לפיכך דם דגים וחגבים טהורים, מותר לאוכלו -- ואפילו כנסו בכלי ושתהו, מותר. ודם חגבים ודגים טמאים, אסור -- משום שהוא תמצית גופן, כחלב בהמה טמאה; ודם שרצים כבשרן, כמו שביארנו.
ב) דם האדם -- אסור מדברי סופרים, אם פירש; ומכין עליו מכת מרדות. אבל דם השיניים, בולעו ואינו נמנע. הרי שנשך בפת, ויצא עליה דם -- גורד את הדם ואחר כך אוכל, שהרי פירש.
ג) אין חייבין כרת אלא על דם היוצא בשעת שחיטה ונחירה או התזת הראש, כל זמן שיש בו אדמדומית, ועל הדם הכנוס בתוך הלב, ועל דם הקזה כל זמן שהוא מקלח ויוצא. אבל הדם השותת בתחילת הקזה, קודם שיתחיל לקלח, ודם השותת בסוף הקזה, כשיתחיל הדם לפסוק -- אין חייבין עליו, והרי הוא כדם האברים: שדם הקילוח, הוא הדם שהנפש יוצאה בו.
ד) דם התמצית ודם האברין, כגון דם הטחול, ודם הכליות, ודם ביצים, ודם המתכנס ללב בשעת שחיטה, ודם הנמצא בכבד -- אין חייבין עליו כרת. אבל האוכל ממנו כזית -- לוקה, שנאמר "וכל דם לא תאכלו" (ויקרא ז,כו); ובחיוב כרת הוא אומר "כי נפש הבשר בדם היא" (ויקרא יז,יא), אינו חייב כרת אלא על הדם שהנפש יוצאה בו.
ה) השליל הנמצא במעי הבהמה, הרי דמו כדם היילוד: לפיכך הדם הנמצא כנוס בתוך ליבו, חייבין עליו כרת; אבל שאר דמו, הרי הוא כדם האברין.
ו) הלב, בין לצלי בין לקדירה -- קורעו ומוציא את דמו, ואחר כך מולחו. ואם בישל הלב ולא קרעו -- קורעו אחר שבישלו, ומותר; ואם לא קרעו -- אם היה בו כזית דם, חייב עליו כרת.
ז) הכבד -- אם חתכה והשליכה לתוך החומץ, או לתוך מים רותחין עד שתתלבן -- הרי זו מותרת לבשל אותה אחר כן; וכבר נהגו כל ישראל להבהבה על האור, ואחר כך מבשלין אותה, בין שבישלה לבדה, בין שבישלה עם בשר אחר. וכן מנהג פשוט שאין מבשלין המוח של ראש, ולא קולין אותו -- עד שמהבהבין אותו באור.
ח) הכבד שבישלה, ולא היבהבה על האור ולא חלטה בחומץ או ברותחין -- הרי הקדירה כולה אסורה, הכבד וכל שנתבשל עימה. ומותר לצלות כבד עם הבשר, בשפוד אחד -- והוא, שתהיה הכבד למטה; ואם עבר וצליה למעלה מבשר, הרי זה אוכל. [ט] הטחול -- מותר לבשלו אפילו עם הבשר, שאינו דם אלא בשר הדומה לדם.
ט) השובר מפרקת בהמה קודם שתצא נפשה, הרי הדם נבלע באברים; ואסור לאכול ממנה בשר חי, ואפילו חלטו. אלא כיצד יעשה, יחתוך החתיכה, וימלח יפה יפה -- ואחר כך יבשל או יצלה. וכבר ביארנו שהשוחט בהמה חיה ועוף ולא יצא מהן דם, שהן מותרין.
י) אין הבשר יוצא מידי דמו אלא אם כן מלחו יפה יפה, ומדיחו יפה יפה. כיצד עושה, מדיח הבשר תחילה, ואחר כך מולחו יפה יפה, ומניחו במלחו כדי הילוך מיל; ואחר כך מדיחו יפה יפה, עד שייצאו המים זכים; ומשליכו מיד לתוך מים רותחין, אבל לא לפושרין -- כדי שיתלבן מיד, ולא ייצא דם.
יא) כשמולחין הבשר, אין מולחין אותו אלא בכלי מנוקב; ואין מולחין אלא במלח עבה כחול הגס, שהמלח דק כקמח ייבלע בבשר ולא יוציא דם. וצריך לנפץ הבשר מן המלח, ואחר כך ידיחנו.
יב) כל הדברים האלו, לבשר שצריך לבשלו. אבל לצלי, מולח וצולה מיד. והרוצה לאכול בשר חי -- מולחו יפה יפה ומדיחו יפה יפה, ואחר כך יאכל; ואם חלטו בחומץ, מותר לאוכלו כשהוא חי, ומותר לשתות החומץ שחלטו בו, שאין החומץ מוציא הדם.
יג) חומץ שחלט בו בשר, לא יחלוט בו פעם שנייה; וחתיכה שהאדימה בתוך החומץ -- היא והחומץ אסורין, עד שימלח אותה יפה יפה ויצלה. בשר שהאדים, וכן ביצי בהמה וחיה בקלף שעליהן, וכן העורף שבו המזרקים שהם מלאים דם -- אם חתכן ומלחן כדת, מותר לבשלן; ואם לא חתכן וצלאן בשפוד, וצלה העורף ופיו למטה, או שצלאן כולן על הגחלים -- הרי אלו מותרין.
יד) ראש הבהמה שצלהו בתנור, או בכבשן -- אם תלהו ובית שחיטתו למטה, מותר: שהדם יוצא ושותת. ואם היה בית השחיטה מן הצד, מוחו אסור -- שהדם מתקבץ לתוכו; ושאר הבשר שעל העצמות מבחוץ, מותר. הניח חוטמו למטה -- אם הניח בו גמי או קנה כדי שיישאר פתוח וייצא דמו דרך חוטמו, מותר; ואם לאו, מוחו אסור.
טו) אין מניחין כלי תחת הצלי לקבל מימיו, עד שתכלה כל מראה אדמדומית שבו. וכיצד עושין, משליכין לתוך הכלי מעט מלח, ומניח הכלי עד שייצל; ולוקח השמנונית של מעלה, והמים של מטה שתחת השמנונית אסורה. [טז] פת שחתך עליה בשר צלי, מותר לאוכלה.
טז) דגים ועופות שמלחן זה עם זה -- אפילו בכלי מנוקב, הדגים אסורין: שהדג רפה, ובולע דם היוצא מן העוף. ואין צריך לומר, אם מלח דג עם בשר בהמה או חיה.
יז) עופות שהניחן שלמים, ומילא חללן בשר וביצים, ובישלן -- אסורות: שהרי דם יוצא לתוכן; ואף על פי שמלחן יפה יפה, ואפילו היה הבשר שבתוכן שלוק או צלוי. ואם צלין, הרי אלו מותרות, אף על פי שהבשר שבתוכן חי, ואפילו פיהן למעלה.
יח) בני מעיים שמילאן על דרך זו בבשר צלוי או שלוק, או שמילאן בביצים, ושלקן או קלין -- הרי אלו מותרין, שאין מחזיקין דם בבני מעיים; וכן הורו הגאונים.
יט) עופות שטפלן בבצק, וצלין, בין שלמים בין מחותכין -- אם טפלן בסולת גסה -- אפילו הסמיקה הטפילה, אוכל את הטפילה: מפני שהיא סולת גסה, מתפררת ויוצא הדם. ואם טפלן בקמח חיטין שלתתן -- אם הייתה הטפילה לבנה כמו הכסף, מותר לאכול ממנה; ואם לאו, אסורה. טפלן בשאר קמחין -- אם האדימו, אסורין; ואם לא האדימו, מותרין.
כ) סכין ששחט בה -- אסור לחתוך בה רותח, עד שילבן הסכין, או ישחיזנה כולה במשחזת, או ינעצנה בקרקע קשה עשרה פעמים; ואם חתך בה רותח, מותר. וכן אינו חותך בה צנון וכיוצא בו מדברים החריפים, לכתחילה; ואם הדיח הסכין, או שקינחה בכלי -- מותר לחתוך בו צנון וכיוצא בו, אבל לא רותח.
כא) קערה שמלח בה בשר, אפילו הייתה שועה באבר -- אסור לאכול בה רותח לעולם, שכבר נבלע הדם בחרסיה.




